In the evolving landscape of regulatory governance, few concepts generate as much enthusiasm—and skepticism—as voluntary compliance. Across jurisdictions and different regulatory domains, policymakers increasingly champion the notion that citizens and regulated entities should comply with the law not through coercion, but through intrinsic motivation and shared commitment to public goals. This aspiration promises to transform adversarial regulatory relationships into cooperative partnerships, reduce enforcement costs, and foster genuine behavioral change rather than mere box-ticking compliance.
Yet as Yuval Feldman’s forthcoming book Can the Public be Trusted? The Promise and Perils of Voluntary Compliance (Cambridge University Press, 2025) demonstrates, the reality of implementing voluntary compliance strategies reveals a far more nuanced picture. Focusing on three main case studies in tax, environmental behavior, and public health, the book poses a fundamental question that challenges regulatory orthodoxy: if voluntary compliance offers such compelling benefits, why do regulatory agencies worldwide continue to default to deterrence-based approaches?
Continue reading “Can the Public Be Trusted? Navigating the Complex Terrain of Voluntary Compliance in Modern Regulation”